The existence of bodybuilding competitions in Gaza does not, by itself, disprove the claim that genocide is taking place. The key issue is what the word genocide means under international law. Genocide is not defined as the total destruction of every individual in a population. It concerns acts committed with the intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group.
The recent bodybuilding and strongman competitions in Gaza therefore raise an understandable question: if people are supposedly facing famine, mass displacement and genocide, how can athletes still be muscular enough to compete?
The answer is that a population experiencing catastrophic conditions does not mean that every person is affected equally or at every moment. People can survive, exercise, organise events and experience moments of normality while simultaneously living amid mass death, displacement and deprivation.
Gaza also had a bodybuilding culture before the current war. Competitions existed for years, with young men training in gyms and participating in organised events. During the war, some athletes have continued training despite destroyed facilities, displacement, shortages of food and equipment, and extremely difficult living conditions. For some, sport has become a way of maintaining dignity and preserving a sense of normal life.
This is important because the existence of a bodybuilding competition does not establish that conditions are normal across Gaza. A photograph of athletes posing on a stage tells us something about those particular individuals at that particular moment. It does not tell us that the wider population is safe, well-fed or free from displacement and violence.
The stronger question is therefore not, “How can bodybuilding happen if there is genocide?” but rather, “Does the existence of isolated moments of normality contradict the evidence being presented for genocide?”
It does not necessarily do so.
Genocide is a question of conduct, circumstances and intent. The legal argument concerns whether the overall pattern of actions against a protected population meets the definition of genocide. Supporters of the genocide allegation argue that the scale of killing, destruction, displacement and deprivation demonstrates such a pattern and intent. Israel rejects the allegation.
So, yes, Gaza can contain bodybuilding competitions, weddings, football matches, children playing and people trying to maintain ordinary life while simultaneously experiencing catastrophic conditions.
The bodybuilding competition is not proof that genocide is impossible. If anything, it demonstrates something more human: even under extreme circumstances, people continue trying to live, compete and maintain some form of normality.
