Catlea’s latest single, Why Them?, is a masterful display of intelligent songwriting and sonic depth, a testament to her evolution as an artist who blends introspection with high-energy performances. Opening with a cerebral electric guitar riff that immediately sets a contemplative yet urgent tone, the track unfolds into a mesmerizing journey of self-exploration. Her whisper-pop delivery initially draws the listener into a confessional space before expanding into an atmospheric and dynamic chorus that feels both anthemic and deeply personal. Following in the footsteps of her previous works, including the thought-provoking Lying and the cinematic Crumbling, Catlea once again proves her ability to craft music that is both emotionally intelligent and musically compelling.
Lyrically, Why Them? explores themes of self-worth, misguided affection, and the struggle for self-reliance amidst external pressures. The opening lines, “I don’t make good choices; I avoid them like the plague. Telling myself everything’s okay, but I can’t feel my legs,” set the stage for a narrative steeped in self-doubt and introspection. As the song progresses, Catlea grapples with the expectations of others and the paradox of seeking validation from people who ultimately do not serve her growth. Her ability to translate these complex emotions into concise yet poetic verses highlights her prowess as a songwriter, making the track an evocative anthem for those navigating personal transformation.
Sonically, the track thrives on a fusion of indie pop, rock, and R&B influences, creating a dynamic soundscape that shifts with Catlea’s vocal delivery. The production, helmed by Jason Boshoff and Oscar Garcia-Bragado, incorporates pulsing synths, driving beats, and soaring guitar riffs that build toward a powerful crescendo. The middle eight is particularly sublime, offering a haunting yet intimate moment before launching into an electrifying finale. This structural design gives the song a cinematic ebb and flow, making it feel like an emotional rollercoaster that mirrors the lyrical themes of uncertainty and revelation.
The song’s chorus, “When you ask, ‘why them, not me?’ I ask myself that question every day, honestly,” encapsulates the central tension of the track – questioning why attention and affection are given to others when self-love and discovery remain elusive. This refrain is not just rhetorical; it is an intimate confession that resonates deeply, making the song both deeply relatable and powerfully cathartic. By allowing vulnerability to exist alongside resilience, Catlea crafts a track that serves as both a lament and a declaration of independence.
Beyond its thematic depth, Why Them? is also an impressive feat of vocal performance. Catlea’s timbre is captivating, shifting seamlessly between breathy introspection and immersive intensity. Her unique vocal design adds layers of emotion, ensuring that each lyric lands with impact. The interplay between sensual whispers and full-throated power notes mirrors the push-and-pull of the song’s narrative – desiring connection yet needing separation, seeking answers yet knowing they must come from within.
As the fifth release from her acclaimed concept album Language Barrier, Why Them? solidifies Catlea’s reputation as an artist who defies genre constraints while embracing raw, emotional storytelling. The track’s gender-bending, genre-crossing appeal makes it a standout on playlists centered around love, heartbreak, self-discovery, and empowerment. Whether you are reflecting on past relationships, rediscovering yourself, or simply in search of an impeccably produced indie pop anthem, Why Them? is an essential listen that reaffirms Catlea’s place as one of the most compelling voices in contemporary music. We have added Why Them? to our New Music Spotlight playlist, and our TRIPPY and TIMELESS playlists, whilst we continue to stream the entirety of Catlea‘s phenomenal album, Language Barrier!